Material appropriate to target audience
I feel that the video met the criteria here and achieved a level 4. I placed it here because the clip clearly fits the genre which we can identify is a horror/thriller.
Titles conventional/appropriate?
Yet again I put the video into a level 4 boundary because I feel that the titles fitted the genre and were quite effective; I would suggest that the inspiration for them came from the opening of seven.
Sound/images and technical editing
In this category, I do not feel they were as strong because the music was very dramatic and included a crescendo effect which is more common in trailers opposed to opening sequences so I decided to give them a level 3 here.
Camera work/framing/variety of shot types/mise en scene
I feel that this was done very well and was clearly thought out. The sequence included very well framed shots and effective close ups; which were reinforced by the costume and makeup used on the protagonist in this section. As a consequence of this, I decided to place them in the level 4 boundary.
Editing for meaning/transition effects
I gave them a level 4 here also because editing was almost unnoticed and they effectively used a flash back sequence although I feel it was a bit rushed to fit in in the time constraints.
Overall feel
They have provided and excellent opening sequence and it was very effective and clearly planned and thought through; I really enjoyed it.
Clip; Rivalry
Material appropriate to target audience
For this aspect, I placed them in a level 3 because some aspects were clear but not very well executed.
Titles convention/appropriate
Yet again they fell into a level 3 again because although the titles were ok; I do not feel they reflected the genre and/or was very creative.
Sound/images and technical editing
Once again I graded a level 3 here because the music had some timing issues and was very similar to the Oceans film (Clearly gained inspiration there) but he did play the music himself so I gave him an extra mark.
Camera work/framing/variety of shot types/mise en scene
I graded a level 3 here as some camerawork did not look very good and some aspect were poorly framed. At times the sequence was inconsistent.
Editing for meaning/transitions and effects
I gave a level 2 here because I did not feel editing was effective as I was drawn to it; I found this distracted me.
Overall Feel
I thought the production had a lot of effort put into it but the final outcome was quite amateurish.
Clip; Faceless
Material appropriate to target audience
I gave them a level 4 here because the genre was easily identified as a horror/thriller due to the mise en scene and several conventions.
Titles conventional/appropriate
I scored them highly here in the level 4 boundary because the titles were nicely placed and fitted the genre very well as they flickered in and out.
Sound/images and technical editing
Yet again I scored them highly in the level 4 boundary because the music and editing was well timed with the sequence and was quite effective.
Camera work/framing/variety of shot types/mise en scene
I gave them a lower level 4 here because the framing and camera work was effective; however there was a lighting issue with the door the captive escaped through and the ‘kill room’ was too well lit.
Editing for meaning/transitions and effects
Here they also achieved a level 4 because I didn’t notice the editing and was immersed in the story the pupils were showing.
Overall feel
I would give them a low level 4 on this one, purely because the acting took away the verisimilitude.